AAAmaury Abreu

Philadelphia Needs to Bring Back Its Own Local Currency

By Amaury Abreu

For nearly twenty years Philadelphia had a local currency alongside the dollar, and the currency worked by paying for food and labor and services across a network of thousands of members and hundreds of businesses. The experiment ended because the design depended on a nonprofit who sponsored the concept, and the operating costs ran out to keep the local currency in operation.

The currency was called Equal Dollars, and a nonprofit named Resources for Human Development launched it in 1996 as a mutual credit system in which members earned the currency through work and volunteering and spent it at businesses that agreed to accept it. A volunteer who gave a few hours at the program's food market earned Equal Dollars and carried them to a local shop, and while individuals had the ability to spend the money at local businesses, the businesses themselves did not have a way to spend the currency.

At its height the network held roughly five thousand members, and the idea underneath made sense because it supported local businesses and provided people with the ability to earn local currency that could only be used locally. I think the lesson here is beyond the mechanics of a local currency. The core idea is that for local economic development to happen we need people to earn and spend money locally and we need the city to attract tourism dollars that are spent here in Philadelphia. The idea is to have a currency that can only be used in Philadelphia where individuals and businesses can earn and spend the currency with each other but not anywhere else therefore incentivizing people to spend and invest funds at a local level.

Where Equal Dollars failed is that when a participating business that accepted the currency could not use the money to pay its suppliers, its landlord, and its distributor in Equal Dollars, because none of those parties belonged to the network, so the currency pooled in the hands of the very businesses it was meant to help and many of them ended up giving it away.

Other places have run the same idea with variations of how those local currency programs work and in particular the BerkShares currency, a local currency in Massachusetts, has operated since 2006 where every unit is backed by a dollar on deposit at a local bank and any holder can convert back for a small fee, and that fee together with the reserve itself gives the program a financial footing to make it self-sustaining.

Another example is the Bristol Pound in England. This currency became the first local currency accepted for payment of city taxes, which gave every holder a guaranteed place to spend it, because a currency the government accepts for its own bills carries inherent demand if it has the right incentives.

The Austrian town of Wörgl showed the other half of the lesson back in 1932, when a currency designed to lose a little value each month moved through the town many times faster than the national money beside it, therefore boosting their local economy.

A new Philadelphia version of its local currency would be built on the lesson from other places where the concept has succeeded and failed. The idea should have the local government’s backing where it incentivizes citizens to use that local currency and spend it with businesses and those businesses should be incentivized to accept the local currency and give them the ability to spend the currency to pay city services, taxes, etc.

With the rise of globalization, we forget that our local economy matters since now it is easier to buy from a supplier in another country. We forget that our neighbors may be producing the things that we are buying from someone located hundreds and thousands of miles away. A local currency is supposed to boost local spending where that money stays circulating in our community, it does not replace the US dollar since that would not be possible, but it serves as a supplement where people can get benefits from using that local currency. We already see a version of this with credit card points which can be redeemed for things we want, the incentives are different but the concept is the same, you earn rewards from spending money. A local currency could have similar incentives but created such that it can only be used in the city and nowhere else giving the businesses and individuals a reason to spend it here.

Philadelphia proved for nineteen years that its people will use a currency of their own when the currency has the right incentives. We could take the lessons from our prior experience and others' experiences and create an economy we are proud of as Philadelphians.

Support the Builders Fund

The Amaury Abreu Builders Fund supports candidates who champion builders and practices issue advocacy at the federal, state, and local level.

Paid for by Amaury Abreu Builders Fund. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee.